St. John's Bay Big & Tall Flannel Shirt: Deep JCPenney Clearance Done Right
An 85% markdown — $6.59 down from $44 — is the kind of price that usually means one thing: a specific size and color are being cleared out to make room for new stock, not a storewide event you'll see repeated broadly. In this case, it's a St. John's Bay men's long sleeve regular fit flannel shirt, Big & Tall 4X-Large, in red.
What You're Getting for the Price
St. John's Bay is JCPenney's long-running in-house basics line, and flannel shirts are exactly the kind of product it does reliably well: straightforward, wearable, no surprises. This is a regular-fit long sleeve, built specifically in Big & Tall sizing — a category that's genuinely harder to find well-priced options in, which makes a clearance price like this more valuable than the same discount would be on a standard size run. Red is a classic flannel colorway, easy to pair with jeans or layer under a jacket once temperatures drop.
Why the Price Is This Low
Clearance pricing on a single size/color combination is normal retail behavior, not a sign anything is wrong with the shirt itself — it's simply what happens when a store needs to move remaining inventory in a specific configuration before a new season's stock arrives. The tradeoff is availability: this exact price is tied to this exact size and color, and clearance stock at this depth of discount tends to sell through and not get restocked at the same markdown. If 4X-Large in red is what you need, there's little reason to wait and see if it gets cheaper.
Who Should Buy This
This makes the most sense for anyone who already wears Big & Tall sizing and needs a reliable, everyday flannel — not someone shopping for a specific fit they haven't tried before, since clearance items are final-sale-adjacent in practice even when a technical return window exists. If the size is right, this is about as inexpensive as a flannel shirt from a legitimate retailer gets without waiting for a once-a-year sale event.
Shopping Big & Tall Sizing More Broadly
Big & Tall sizing is a category that's genuinely underserved at a lot of mainstream retailers, which is part of why a deep clearance markdown in this specific size range is worth flagging rather than skipping past. JCPenney has kept a dedicated Big & Tall assortment across several of its own labels, St. John's Bay included, rather than treating it as an afterthought sizing extension — which generally means better proportions (sleeve length, body length, not just a wider standard cut) than a brand that simply scales up its regular sizing. If 4X isn't your size but you do shop Big & Tall regularly, it's worth checking JCPenney's Big & Tall section directly rather than only this listing, since clearance pricing at this depth tends to appear across multiple sizes in a line at similar points in the season, not just the one currently marked down.
Worth a final practical note: check JCPenney's return window specifically for clearance-priced items before ordering, since final-sale terms can differ from the standard return policy applied to full-price merchandise, and it varies enough by category that it's worth confirming rather than assuming.
The Bottom Line
At $6.59, this isn't a discount worth chasing for its own sake — it's worth buying because it's a genuinely useful, well-fitting basic at a price that's hard to beat, for the specific size it's available in. Check your size against JCPenney's own size chart before ordering, since clearance items in Big & Tall sizing can run differently than standard cuts.
Browse more markdowns on JCPenney's deals page, or check current JCPenney coupon codes in case free shipping or an extra discount applies at checkout.
